Dopamine Signaling And The Neurology Of Scam Victims

Principal Category: Neurology

Author:
•  Tim McGuinness, PhD DFin, MCPO, MAnth – Anthropologist, Scientist, Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.

Abstract:

Dopamine signaling plays a crucial role in scammers’ manipulation of their victims, with techniques like anchoring and association being particularly effective. In the case of cryptocurrency scams, scammers anchor their victims’ expectations by presenting initial investments as highly profitable, which triggers dopamine release associated with excitement and anticipation of rewards.

This manipulation is reinforced by associating the scam with success stories or testimonials, further enhancing credibility and triggering dopamine-driven motivation. Additionally, scammers create a sense of urgency through limited-time offers, heightening stress and anxiety which disrupts rational decision-making and enhances the victim’s susceptibility. These techniques exploit the brain’s reward system, making victims more likely to comply with the scammers’ demands.

Dopamine Signaling Manipulation in Scam Victims

Dopamine Signaling, along with Amygdala Manipulation, is one of the two main manipulations of the brain criminals use to control scam victims.

Please note: this article is intended to introduce the subject, not a comprehensive review of the neurology involved.

We have broken it out into general information and then specifically for three dominant types of deception-based crimes: Relationship Scams, Crypto Investment Scams, and Sextortion Scams. Of course, this is applicable to virtually all types of scams and fraud.

Dopamine Signaling in the Brain: An Overview

Dopamine is a neurotransmitter in the brain that plays a significant role in reward, motivation, and pleasure. It is involved in various functions, including motor control, mood regulation, and the reinforcement of rewarding behaviors. Dopamine signaling refers to the process by which dopamine is released by neurons, travels across synapses, and binds to dopamine receptors on adjacent neurons, initiating a cellular response. This process is critical for the brain’s reward system, influencing how we experience pleasure and reinforcement.

Dopamine and the Reward System

The brain’s reward system involves several interconnected brain regions, primarily the mesolimbic pathway, which includes the ventral tegmental area (VTA) and the nucleus accumbens. When we engage in activities that are enjoyable or beneficial, such as eating, socializing, or achieving goals, dopamine is released in these areas, creating a sense of pleasure and reinforcing the behavior. This mechanism encourages the repetition of behaviors that are perceived as rewarding.

Dopamine Signaling and Scam Victims

Scammers exploit the brain’s reward system by manipulating dopamine signaling to create a sense of reward, anticipation, and urgency in their victims. Here’s how dopamine signaling is related to scam victims and manipulation:

1. Promise of Rewards: Scammers often promise large rewards, whether financial gain, romantic affection, or other desirable outcomes. This promise triggers the brain’s reward system, releasing dopamine and creating a sense of excitement and anticipation.
2. Variable Rewards: Similar to gambling, scammers may use variable rewards to keep victims engaged. The uncertainty of the reward (e.g., winning a lottery or receiving a love message) can lead to higher dopamine release, making the experience more addictive.
3. Social Manipulation: Scammers often build trust and create emotional connections with their victims. Positive social interactions and the promise of a relationship can trigger dopamine release, reinforcing the victim’s attachment and willingness to comply with the scammer’s requests.
4. Urgency and Pressure: By creating a sense of urgency or fear (e.g., limited-time offers, threats of legal action), scammers induce stress and anxiety. Stressful situations can lead to dopamine dysregulation, impairing decision-making and increasing susceptibility to manipulation.
5. Emotional Roller Coaster: Scammers often manipulate their victims’ emotions, alternating between kindness and threats. This emotional roller coaster can lead to fluctuating dopamine levels, causing confusion and making the victim more likely to comply to seek relief or reward.

Manipulation Techniques Leveraging Dopamine

• Love and Affection Scams: Scammers create romantic scenarios, exploiting the dopamine release associated with love and affection. This makes victims more willing to send money or personal information.
• Financial Scams: Promises of quick and large financial returns trigger dopamine-driven excitement and risk-taking behavior, making victims more likely to invest in fraudulent schemes.
• Phishing and Impersonation: Scammers create urgent and alarming scenarios (e.g., account breaches, legal threats) that cause stress and anxiety, disrupting dopamine signaling and impairing rational judgment.

Manipulation techniques often leverage the brain’s dopamine pathways to influence behavior, decision-making, and emotions. Understanding how these techniques exploit dopamine signaling can help individuals recognize and resist manipulation. Here’s an expanded look at how manipulation techniques utilize dopamine:

1. Dopamine Signaling – Reward Systems and Positive Reinforcement

Technique:

Manipulators often use positive reinforcement to create associations between specific behaviors and rewards. This can include compliments, gifts, attention, or praise.

How it works:

When a person receives a reward, their brain releases dopamine, reinforcing the behavior that led to the reward. Over time, the individual becomes conditioned to repeat the behavior to continue receiving the positive stimulus.

Generalized Examples

In a workplace, a manipulative boss might frequently praise an employee for working late, creating a dopamine-driven association between overworking and receiving approval.

In a scam, the criminal can create a dopamine-driven association between sending money and the promise of a visit,

Examples of Relationship Scammers Using Reward Systems and Positive Reinforcement

Scenario:

A relationship scammer contacts a victim through a social media platform or dating app, aiming to build an emotional connection to manipulate and eventually defraud the victim.

Techniques:

Example: Compliments and Flattery:

Example: The scammer frequently compliments the victim on their appearance, intelligence, and kindness. “You’re the most beautiful person I’ve ever met. I’ve never felt this way about anyone before.” This is called ‘Love Bombing’

Positive Reinforcement: These compliments make the victim feel valued and appreciated, releasing dopamine and creating a sense of happiness associated with the scammer’s attention.

Example: Romantic Gestures:

Example: The scammer sends virtual flowers, e-cards, or romantic poems regularly. Occasionally, they might send small gifts, like inexpensive jewelry or souvenirs.

Positive Reinforcement: These gestures reinforce the victim’s belief that the scammer genuinely cares for them, encouraging the victim to invest more emotionally and financially in the relationship.

Example: Expressions of Love and Commitment:

Example: The scammer often declares their love and talks about a future together. “I can’t wait for us to finally be together and start our life together. You make me so happy.”

Positive Reinforcement: These declarations create a sense of security and future promise, making the victim feel special and deeply connected to the scammer.

Example: Attention and Availability:

Example: The scammer is initially always available to chat, offering a sympathetic ear and showing interest in the victim’s daily life. “How was your day? I’ve been thinking about you all day.”

Positive Reinforcement: This constant attention makes the victim feel important and understood, reinforcing their attachment to the scammer.

Example: Occasional Financial Gains:

Example: If the scammer asks for small amounts of money and then “returns” it as a show of trust, they might occasionally “gift” the victim money or claim to invest and show a small profit. “I made some money in a deal and wanted to share it with you because you mean so much to me.”

Positive Reinforcement: These actions build trust and make the victim more likely to send larger amounts of money in the future.

Examples of Crypto Investment Scammers Using Reward Systems and Positive Reinforcement

Scenario:

A crypto investment scammer contacts a potential victim, promising high returns on cryptocurrency investments. The scammer uses positive reinforcement to build trust and encourage the victim to invest more money.

Techniques:

Example: Initial Small Profits:

Example: The scammer advises the victim to invest a small amount of money, which is quickly reported to grow. “Congratulations! Your $100 investment has turned into $150 in just a week. Imagine what we can achieve with a bigger investment!”

Positive Reinforcement: These initial gains trigger dopamine release and build the victim’s confidence in the scammer’s investment acumen, encouraging further investment.

Example: Frequent Updates and Success Stories:

Example: The scammer regularly shares updates about how well the investment is doing and shares stories of other investors who have made significant profits. “Look at how much John made last month! You’re on the same track!”

Positive Reinforcement: These updates keep the victim engaged and optimistic about the investment’s potential, reinforcing their decision to invest more money.

Example: Exclusive Opportunities:

Example: The scammer offers the victim access to exclusive investment opportunities with even higher potential returns. “I have a special opportunity just for my top clients. If you invest an additional $500, you could see returns of 50% within two weeks.”

Positive Reinforcement: This creates a sense of being special and privileged, making the victim more likely to increase their investment.

Example: Encouraging Community and Support:

Example: The scammer may involve the victim in an online community of other “investors” who share their success stories and support each other. “Join our exclusive Telegram group where you can see how others are benefiting from our strategies.”

Positive Reinforcement: The community’s positive feedback and shared success stories create a supportive environment, reinforcing the victim’s belief in the legitimacy and profitability of the investment.

Example: Occasional Partial Withdrawals:

Example: The scammer allows the victim to withdraw a small portion of their profits, demonstrating that the investment is real and accessible. “You can withdraw $200 of your profits now to see that this is real money.”

Positive Reinforcement: This partial withdrawal builds trust and reassures the victim, making them more likely to reinvest and add more funds.

Examples of Sextortion Scammers Using Reward Systems and Positive Reinforcement

Scenario:

A sextortion scammer contacts a victim through social media or dating apps, aiming to establish a relationship and gain compromising material or manipulate the victim for financial gain.

Techniques:

Example: Building Trust with Flattery and Compliments:

Example: The scammer frequently compliments the victim on their appearance, personality, and intelligence. “You’re so attractive and smart, I can’t believe I’m talking to someone like you.”

Positive Reinforcement: These compliments make the victim feel appreciated and valued, releasing dopamine and creating a sense of happiness associated with the scammer’s attention.

Example: Engaging in Romantic Conversations:

Example: The scammer engages in intimate and romantic conversations, making the victim feel special and desired. “I feel such a strong connection with you. I’ve never felt this way before.”

Positive Reinforcement: The romantic dialogue builds an emotional bond, making the victim more likely to trust and open up to the scammer.

Example: Sending Personal Photos:

Example: The scammer sends photos of themselves (often stolen from real people) to build a sense of intimacy and trust. “Here’s a photo of me relaxing at home. I’d love to see a picture of you too.”

Positive Reinforcement: Receiving personal photos can make the victim feel closer to the scammer and more comfortable sharing their own photos in return.

Example: Creating a Sense of Exclusivity:

Example: The scammer convinces the victim that they share a unique and special bond. “I’ve never shared this side of me with anyone else. You’re the only one who understands me.”

Positive Reinforcement: This sense of exclusivity makes the victim feel special and privileged, reinforcing their attachment to the scammer and their willingness to comply with requests.

Example: Gradual Requests for Intimate Content:

Example: The scammer starts by asking for innocent photos or videos, gradually progressing to more intimate or compromising content. “You look so beautiful in that dress. Can I see more of you?”

Positive Reinforcement: Each time the victim complies with a request and receives positive feedback, it reinforces their behavior and makes them more likely to continue sharing content.

Example: Praising Compliance:

Example: The scammer praises the victim each time they comply with a request for intimate content. “Wow, you look amazing! Thank you for sharing this with me.”

Positive Reinforcement: The praise makes the victim feel good about their actions, reinforcing their willingness to continue complying.

Example: False Promises of Future Rewards:

Example: The scammer promises future rewards such as meeting in person or a committed relationship. “I can’t wait until we can finally be together. I’ll make you so happy.”

Positive Reinforcement: These promises create a hopeful outlook for the victim, making them more likely to continue engaging with the scammer and following their instructions.

2. Dopamine Signaling – Intermittent Reinforcement

Technique:

Unlike consistent rewards, intermittent reinforcement involves providing rewards unpredictably. This variability can make the behavior more ingrained and harder to extinguish.

How it works:

Dopamine release is particularly strong when rewards are unexpected. The uncertainty of the reward increases the anticipation and craving, making the person more likely to continue the behavior in hopes of receiving the reward.

A Generalized Example:

In gambling, players receive rewards (wins) on an unpredictable schedule, which strongly activates the dopamine system, encouraging them to keep playing despite losses.

Example: Relationship Scammers Using Intermittent Reinforcement

Scenario:

A relationship scammer initiates contact with a victim through a dating app. The scammer creates a convincing and charming online persona, establishing an emotional connection with the victim over several weeks.

Techniques:

Example: Initial Flattery and Attention:

The scammer bombards the victim with compliments, loving messages, and constant attention. This initial phase creates a strong dopamine release in the victim, reinforcing the positive feelings associated with the scammer.

Example: Intermittent Communication:

After establishing a bond, the scammer begins to reduce the frequency and predictability of their messages. Sometimes, they might send a flurry of affectionate texts and then disappear for a few days without explanation. This intermittent reinforcement keeps the victim’s anticipation and emotional investment high, as they crave the return of the scammer’s attention.

Example: Promises of a Future Together:

The scammer talks about future plans and dreams of being together, creating a sense of anticipation and excitement. However, these promises are vague and never materialize, keeping the victim in a state of longing and hope.

Example: Occasional Gifts or Declarations of Love:

Every now and then, the scammer might send a small gift, such as flowers, or make a grand declaration of love. These sporadic rewards trigger a significant dopamine release, reinforcing the victim’s emotional attachment and the desire to keep the relationship going.

Example: Requests for Money:

After the victim is deeply emotionally invested, the scammer begins to request financial assistance, citing emergencies, investment opportunities, or travel expenses to finally meet. The requests are interspersed with periods of affection and attention, maintaining the victim’s emotional dependence and hope for a future together.

Example: Crypto Investment Scammers Using Intermittent Reinforcement

Scenario:

A crypto investment scammer contacts a potential victim, promising high returns on investments in cryptocurrency. They create a sense of urgency and excitement around the investment opportunity.

Techniques:

Example: Initial Gains:

The scammer advises the victim to make a small initial investment, which is quickly followed by reports of substantial gains. The victim sees their account balance increasing, which triggers a strong dopamine release and reinforces the idea that the investment is profitable.

Example: Unpredictable Wins:

The scammer provides occasional updates showing the investment’s success. Sometimes the reported gains are significant, and other times they are modest, creating an unpredictable pattern. This variability keeps the victim engaged and hopeful for larger future gains.

Example: Building Anticipation:

The scammer occasionally hints at upcoming lucrative opportunities or exclusive deals, creating anticipation and excitement. The victim stays invested, both emotionally and financially, hoping to capitalize on these potential windfalls.

Example: Requests for Additional Investments:

Intermittently, the scammer encourages the victim to invest more money to maximize returns or to recover from minor, fabricated losses. These requests are mixed with periods of apparent success, keeping the victim’s confidence and investment growing.

Example: Partial Withdrawals:

To build trust, the scammer might allow the victim to withdraw a small portion of their investment, showing that the returns are real. This partial reinforcement strengthens the victim’s belief in the legitimacy of the investment, leading them to invest even more.

Examples of Sextortion Scammers Using Intermittent Reinforcement

Scenario:

A sextortion scammer engages with a victim through social media or dating apps, aiming to manipulate the victim into providing compromising material for financial gain.

NOTE: This approach is usually employed with older adults, not teens. In the case of teens, the scammers want to begin and end the scam very rapidly, sometimes in hours. Intermittent Reinforcement does not work on this time scale.

Techniques:

Example: Occasional Affectionate Messages:

Example: The scammer alternates between periods of intense romantic communication and periods of minimal or no contact. “I miss you so much, can’t wait to talk again” followed by days of silence.

Intermittent Reinforcement: The unpredictability of affectionate messages keeps the victim craving the scammer’s attention and more likely to comply with requests to regain that affection.

Example: Inconsistent Response Times:

Example: The scammer varies the time it takes to respond to the victim’s messages, sometimes replying instantly and other times taking hours or days.

Intermittent Reinforcement: This erratic communication pattern makes the victim anxious and eager for the next interaction, increasing their attachment and willingness to please the scammer.

Example: Variable Compliments and Criticism:

Example: The scammer mixes praise with occasional criticism. “You look stunning today! But I noticed you haven’t been replying quickly, are you losing interest?”

Intermittent Reinforcement: The victim becomes more motivated to seek approval and avoid criticism, thus becoming more susceptible to the scammer’s demands.

Example: Fluctuating Levels of Intimacy:

Example: The scammer alternates between sharing intimate, personal stories and being emotionally distant. One day they might say, “I feel so close to you, like I can tell you anything,” and the next day, they might share very little.

Intermittent Reinforcement: This keeps the victim guessing and more invested in the relationship, hoping to return to the intimate connection.

Example: Random Rewards for Compliance:

Example: The scammer provides occasional rewards, such as expressing love or sending a photo, in response to the victim sharing intimate content or money. “I love that picture you sent, here’s one of me too” followed by no response for subsequent pictures.

Intermittent Reinforcement: The unpredictability of rewards makes the victim continue complying with the scammer’s requests, hoping to receive another positive response.

Example: Unpredictable Promises of Future Meetings:

Example: The scammer makes inconsistent promises about meeting in person, sometimes saying they can meet soon and other times claiming they have to delay. “I can’t wait to see you next month” followed by “Something came up, we’ll have to reschedule.”

Intermittent Reinforcement: This creates an emotional rollercoaster for the victim, who becomes increasingly eager and willing to do whatever it takes to make the meeting happen.

Example: Alternating Between Threats and Reassurance:

Example: The scammer threatens to share compromising material and then reassures the victim that they won’t if certain demands are met. “If you don’t send me more pictures, I’ll post these online” followed by “I’m sorry, I don’t want to hurt you, just trust me.”

Intermittent Reinforcement: The victim is caught in a cycle of fear and relief, making them more likely to comply with the scammer’s demands to avoid potential threats.

3. Dopamine Signaling – Creating a Sense of Anticipation

Technique:

Manipulators may build anticipation for a future reward, creating a sense of excitement and expectation.

How it works:

The anticipation itself can trigger dopamine release. By keeping individuals in a state of expectation, manipulators can maintain engagement and control over their actions.

A Generalized Example:

In marketing, a company might tease the release of a new product with limited information, creating a buzz and anticipation that keeps potential customers engaged and eagerly awaiting the launch.

Examples of How Relationship Scammers Use Creating a Sense of Anticipation

Example: Promise of Meeting in Person:

Example: The scammer establishes a romantic connection online and after some time, promises to visit the victim. They might say, “I’ve saved up enough money, and I’m planning to come see you next month! I can’t wait for us to finally be together.”

Anticipation: The victim becomes emotionally invested in the upcoming meeting, making them more likely to comply with financial requests to ensure the visit happens, such as paying for travel expenses or unforeseen emergencies.

Example: Future Plans and Dreams:

Example: The scammer talks about a shared future, discussing dreams of marriage, buying a house together, or starting a family. They might say, “I can see us living in a beautiful home together, raising kids and growing old together.”

Anticipation: This creates a hopeful and eager emotional state in the victim, who may then feel more compelled to send money or gifts to support the realization of these future plans.

Example: Gradual Disclosure of Personal Stories:

Example: The scammer shares personal and intimate stories gradually, revealing more over time. For instance, “There’s something very personal I need to tell you about my past, but I need to know I can trust you first.”

Anticipation: The victim becomes curious and eager to learn more, investing emotionally and financially to demonstrate their trustworthiness and deepen the connection.

Example: Hints of a Surprise:

Example: The scammer hints at a big surprise or a special gift they have for the victim but doesn’t reveal what it is immediately. They might say, “I have a special surprise for you, but you’ll have to wait until next week to find out what it is!”

Anticipation: The victim becomes excited and looks forward to the surprise, which keeps them engaged and more willing to continue the relationship, often leading to further financial exploitation.

Example: Teasing a Life Change:

Example: The scammer discusses significant life changes that involve the victim, such as moving to be closer or starting a business together. For example, “I’ve been thinking about relocating to your city. I’m tired of being so far away from you.”

Anticipation: The victim becomes excited about the prospect of having the scammer close by, making them more likely to help financially with the supposed moving costs or business start-up expenses.

Example: Building Up to a Romantic Event:

Example: The scammer plans a romantic event or getaway, creating excitement and anticipation. They might say, “I’ve planned a romantic weekend getaway for us. It’s going to be perfect. Just a few more weeks!”

Anticipation: The victim becomes emotionally invested in the planned event, making them more likely to provide money to cover the costs or handle unexpected issues that arise before the trip.

Example: Countdown to a Special Occasion:

Example: The scammer sets a date for a special occasion, such as their online anniversary or a significant holiday, and builds anticipation leading up to it. For instance, “Our one-year anniversary is coming up. I have something special planned for us.”

Anticipation: The victim looks forward to the occasion and may be more willing to spend money on gifts or preparations, believing it will strengthen their relationship.

Example: The Let-Down & the Emotional Roller Coaster

The letdown when the scammer never actually shows up is a critical part of the manipulation process in relationship scams. This tactic is designed to exploit the victim’s emotional investment and can have significant psychological effects, which in turn can make the victim more susceptible to further manipulation. Here’s how the letdown plays into the scam:

Heightened Anticipation: The victim experiences intense excitement and anticipation leading up to the promised meeting or event. This emotional high makes the eventual letdown even more impactful.

Crushing Disappointment: When the scammer fails to show up, the victim feels a profound sense of disappointment and sadness. This emotional low can create a sense of vulnerability and helplessness.

Let-Down Example: Increased Manipulation

Sympathy and Guilt: Scammers often exploit the victim’s disappointment by creating elaborate excuses for why they couldn’t make it, such as a sudden illness or an emergency. This elicits sympathy from the victim and can shift the focus from the scammer’s failure to the scammer’s “misfortune.”

Renewed Promises: After the letdown, scammers usually make new promises to meet or offer compensation, which renews the victim’s hope and keeps them emotionally engaged. This cycle of anticipation and disappointment reinforces the scammer’s control over the victim.

Let-Down Example: Financial Exploitation

Unexpected Costs: Scammers might claim that they couldn’t meet due to unexpected financial issues (e.g., their car broke down, they missed their flight, they were robbed), and ask the victim for money to resolve these problems. The victim, eager to finally meet the scammer and alleviate their own disappointment, may comply.

Investment in the Relationship: The victim’s emotional investment often translates into a financial one. After the letdown, they might be more inclined to send money or gifts to ensure the next promised meeting happens, believing that the next time will be different.

Let-Down Example: Psychological Impact

Cognitive Dissonance: The victim may experience cognitive dissonance, where their actions (sending money, emotional investment) don’t align with the reality of the situation (the scammer not showing up). To reduce this dissonance, they might rationalize the scammer’s behavior and continue to believe in the relationship.

Attachment and Dependency: The cycle of anticipation and letdown can create a trauma bond, where the victim becomes emotionally dependent on the scammer. Despite the letdowns, the victim continues to seek the scammer’s approval and validation, making it harder to break free.

Let-Down Example Scenario

1. 1. 1. 1. Initial Excitement: The scammer promises to visit the victim, creating a detailed story about their trip and what they plan to do together.
         2. Letdown Event: On the day of the supposed meeting, the scammer contacts the victim with an emergency excuse (e.g., “I was in an accident,” “I missed my flight due to a family emergency”).
         3. Emotional Appeal: The scammer expresses regret and sadness about not being able to meet, asking for understanding and sometimes financial help to fix the situation.
         4. Renewed Hope: The scammer makes a new promise to meet soon, reigniting the victim’s anticipation and keeping them emotionally invested.

Examples of How Crypto Investment Scammers Use Creating a Sense of Anticipation

Crypto investment scammers effectively use the tactic of creating a sense of anticipation to manipulate their victims into investing more money. By leveraging psychological triggers, they keep the victims emotionally invested and hopeful for big returns. Here are examples of how they do this:

Example: Promising Imminent Big Returns

Initial Contact and Investment: The scammer convinces the victim to make an initial small investment, promising that it’s just the beginning and that bigger returns are on the horizon.

Showing Fake Growth: The scammer provides fake account statements or shows the victim a rigged online platform where their initial investment appears to grow rapidly.

Building Anticipation: The scammer frequently updates the victim about upcoming market opportunities, such as an imminent price spike for a particular cryptocurrency, claiming that now is the perfect time to invest more to maximize returns.

Example: Creating Urgency:

The scammer might claim that the opportunity is time-sensitive, adding pressure and making the victim feel that they must act quickly or miss out on significant profits.

Example: Announcing Exclusive Opportunities

Exclusive Access: The scammer claims to have access to exclusive cryptocurrency investment opportunities that are not available to the general public, building a sense of exclusivity and privilege.

Teasing Big Announcements: The scammer teases upcoming announcements of new cryptocurrency projects or partnerships that will supposedly drive the value of their investment sky-high.

Countdowns and Deadlines: They might use countdowns or deadlines for investment opportunities, making the victim feel they must act quickly to secure their place in the exclusive deal.

Example: Fake Success Stories

Success Testimonials: The scammer shares stories of other “investors” who supposedly made huge profits through similar investments, creating anticipation that the victim will experience the same success.

Future Predictions: They frequently predict massive future gains, encouraging the victim to keep investing to not miss out on the predicted windfall.

Regular Updates: The scammer sends regular updates about how the market is moving as expected and how the investment is on track to deliver the promised returns, keeping the victim’s hopes and anticipation high.

Example: Partial Withdrawals

Allowing Small Withdrawals: To build trust and anticipation, the scammer may allow the victim to withdraw a small amount of profit initially, reinforcing the belief that the investment is legitimate.

Bigger Promises: After the small withdrawal, the scammer claims that larger profits are just around the corner and encourages the victim to reinvest or add more money to achieve these bigger returns.

Example: Fake Market Insights

Insider Tips: The scammer provides the victim with “insider” tips on upcoming market movements, fostering the belief that they have advanced knowledge and that acting on this information will lead to substantial profits.

Hyping Market Events: They hype up upcoming market events, such as new coin launches, regulatory changes, or tech developments, claiming these will cause significant price increases, creating a sense of urgency and anticipation for the victim to invest more.

Impact of Anticipation on Victims

Increased Financial Commitment: The sense of anticipation makes victims more likely to invest additional funds, believing that a significant payoff is imminent.

Emotional Manipulation: Victims become emotionally tied to the anticipated returns, making them less likely to heed warnings and more likely to overlook red flags.

Continued Investment: Even when minor setbacks occur, the anticipation of eventual large returns can keep victims invested in the scam, hoping their patience and investment will eventually pay off

Examples of How Sextortion Scammers Use Creating a Sense of Anticipation

Creating a Sense of Anticipation by Sextortion Scammers: Sextortion scammers effectively use the tactic of creating a sense of anticipation to manipulate their victims, maintaining control and maximizing their leverage.

NOTE: This approach is usually employed with older adults, not teens. In the case of teens, the scammers want to begin and end the scam very rapidly, sometimes in hours. Intermittent Reinforcement does not work on this time scale.

Here are examples of how they do this:

Example: Promising Intimate Interaction

Initial Flirtation and Connection: The scammer establishes an online relationship with the victim, engaging in flirtatious and intimate conversations to build a sense of connection.

Teasing Future Intimacy: The scammer hints at or explicitly promises future intimate interactions, such as video calls or meet-ups, to keep the victim engaged and hopeful.

Postponing with Excuses: When the time comes for the promised interaction, the scammer provides plausible excuses for why it can’t happen yet, keeping the victim anticipating the next opportunity.

Example: Offering Exclusive Content

Suggestive Messages: The scammer sends suggestive messages or photos, implying that more explicit content will be shared in the future.

Building Excitement: They create a sense of excitement by describing the exclusive content they will share, making the victim eager to receive it.

Conditional Sharing: The scammer sets conditions for sharing the content, such as requiring the victim to send their own explicit photos or videos first, creating a cycle of anticipation and compliance.

Example: Promising Privacy and Discretion

Reassuring Privacy: The scammer assures the victim that their interactions will remain private, building trust and encouraging the victim to share intimate content.

Discussing Future Secrets: They talk about the exciting secrets they will share in the future, making the victim feel special and privileged.

Delaying Disclosure: When the victim starts to feel suspicious, the scammer delays any negative consequences by promising that the shared content is safe and will never be leaked, maintaining a sense of security and anticipation.

Example: Creating an Illusion of Relationship

Emotional Engagement: The scammer creates an illusion of a genuine emotional relationship, sharing personal stories and expressing affection to build a deep connection.

Future Plans: They discuss future plans together, such as meeting in person or starting a relationship, to keep the victim emotionally invested.

Conditional Steps: The scammer asks the victim to take certain steps or provide specific content to progress the relationship, creating a cycle of anticipation and action.

Example: Promising Rewards for Compliance

Incentivizing Actions: The scammer promises rewards, such as additional intimate content or exclusive attention, if the victim complies with their demands.

Gradual Escalation: They gradually escalate their demands, each time promising a greater reward, keeping the victim engaged and compliant.

Withholding Rewards: The scammer occasionally withholds the promised rewards, using the victim’s anticipation and desire for those rewards to manipulate them further.

Example: Threats with Deferred Consequences

Imminent Exposure Threats: The scammer threatens to expose the victim’s intimate content unless they comply with certain demands, creating a sense of immediate danger.

Delaying Exposure: They delay the threatened exposure by extending deadlines or offering the victim chances to comply, creating a cycle of fear and anticipation.

Offering Temporary Reprieve: The scammer occasionally offers temporary reprieves, making the victim believe they have successfully avoided exposure, which keeps them engaged and willing to comply with future demands.

Impact of Anticipation on Victims

Emotional Manipulation: The anticipation of rewards or fear of exposure keeps victims emotionally engaged, making it difficult for them to break free from the scammer’s control.

Increased Compliance: Victims are more likely to comply with the scammer’s demands, whether it’s providing more content, money, or personal information, in hopes of achieving the promised rewards or avoiding the threatened consequences.

Prolonged Victimization: The sense of anticipation prolongs the victim’s entrapment in the scam, leading to greater emotional distress, financial loss, and reputational damage.

4. Dopamine Signaling – Social Validation and Approval

Technique:

Social manipulators often seek to provide or withhold social validation and approval to control behavior.

How it works:

Social acceptance and approval are powerful triggers for dopamine release. Individuals crave social validation, and manipulators can exploit this by offering approval to reinforce desired behaviors or withholding it to discourage undesired ones.

A Generalized Example:

On social media, influencers might use likes, comments, and shares as a form of social validation to manipulate followers into engaging with content, promoting products, or adopting certain behaviors.

Examples of How Relationship Scammers Use Social Validation and Approval

Relationship scammers are adept at exploiting the brain’s dopamine signaling pathways by providing social validation and approval to their victims. This manipulation creates a powerful emotional dependency and reinforces the scammer’s control. Here are examples of how this works:

Dopamine plays a crucial role in how we feel about social interactions, achievements, and recognition. When we receive social validation and approval, our brain releases dopamine, making us feel good and encouraging us to seek out more of the same positive feedback.

Example: Compliments and Flattery

Initial Interaction: The scammer begins by showering the victim with compliments and flattery, making them feel attractive, valued, and special. Dopamine Effect: These positive affirmations trigger a release of dopamine in the victim’s brain, creating a pleasurable and rewarding experience.

Continuous Validation: The scammer continues to provide regular compliments and positive feedback, reinforcing the victim’s self-esteem and emotional connection. Dopamine Effect: The ongoing validation keeps the victim’s dopamine levels elevated, fostering an emotional dependence on the scammer’s approval.

Example: Expressing Love and Affection

Rapid Escalation of Affection: The scammer quickly escalates the relationship, expressing love and deep affection early on. Dopamine Effect: Hearing expressions of love and affection stimulates dopamine release, making the victim feel euphoric and cherished.

Frequent Romantic Gestures: The scammer sends romantic messages, virtual gifts, and affectionate gestures to maintain a high level of emotional engagement. Dopamine Effect: These romantic interactions continually boost the victim’s dopamine levels, strengthening their emotional bond with the scammer.

Example: Creating an Illusion of Exclusive Connection

Exclusive Attention: The scammer makes the victim feel like they are the only person in their life, giving them exclusive attention and prioritizing their interactions. Dopamine Effect: The feeling of being uniquely important to someone enhances dopamine release, reinforcing the victim’s attachment to the scammer.

Building Trust and Intimacy: The scammer shares personal stories and secrets, creating a sense of intimacy and trust. Dopamine Effect: The deepening of perceived emotional intimacy increases dopamine levels, making the victim feel even more connected and valued.

Example: Positive Reinforcement through Milestones

Celebrating Relationship Milestones: The scammer celebrates various milestones in the relationship, such as anniversaries, shared dreams, or mutual goals. Dopamine Effect: Achieving these milestones provides a sense of accomplishment and satisfaction, releasing dopamine and reinforcing the relationship’s importance.

Encouraging Future Plans: The scammer frequently talks about future plans together, such as traveling, meeting in person, or building a life together. Dopamine Effect: Anticipation of these future rewards keeps the victim’s dopamine levels high, maintaining their excitement and commitment to the relationship.

Example: Social Media Validation

Public Displays of Affection: The scammer may post affectionate comments, pictures, or statuses on social media, publicly validating the relationship. Dopamine Effect: Public recognition and validation from social media interactions boost the victim’s dopamine levels, enhancing their sense of social approval and belonging.

Engaging with Victim’s Posts: The scammer actively engages with the victim’s social media posts, liking, commenting, and sharing them. Dopamine Effect: Each social media interaction acts as a micro-reward, releasing small amounts of dopamine and reinforcing the victim’s emotional dependency on the scammer’s approval.

Relationship scammers skillfully leverage social validation and approval to manipulate their victims, creating a powerful dopamine-driven dependency. By consistently providing compliments, affection, exclusive attention, and public validation, scammers exploit the brain’s reward system to maintain control and deepen their emotional hold on the victim. Understanding these tactics can help individuals recognize the signs of manipulation and protect themselves from falling victim to such scams.

Examples of How Crypto Investment Scammers Use Social Validation and Approval

Example: Success Stories and Testimonials

Sharing Success Stories: The scammer shares fabricated or exaggerated success stories of previous investors who have supposedly made significant profits. Dopamine Effect: Hearing about others’ financial success triggers dopamine release in the victim, creating excitement and the desire to experience similar rewards.

Fake Testimonials: The scammer provides fake testimonials from people claiming to have made substantial returns on their investments. Dopamine Effect: Positive testimonials act as social proof, reinforcing the victim’s belief in the scam’s legitimacy and releasing dopamine as they imagine their potential success.

Example: Engaging in Online Investment Communities

Active Participation in Forums: The scammer actively participates in online investment forums or social media groups, offering advice and sharing supposed success stories. Dopamine Effect: The engagement and validation from community members boost the victim’s dopamine levels, making them feel part of a successful and knowledgeable group.

Creating Fake Profiles: The scammer creates multiple fake profiles to simulate a community of satisfied investors who validate each other’s success stories. Dopamine Effect: Interaction with these fake profiles provides continuous social validation, enhancing the victim’s dopamine response and trust in the scam.

Example: Personalized Positive Feedback

Regular Updates on Investment Growth: The scammer sends regular updates about the supposed growth of the victim’s investment, showing increasing profits. Dopamine Effect: Seeing the numbers go up gives the victim a sense of accomplishment and releases dopamine, reinforcing their decision to invest.

Personalized Praise: The scammer provides personalized praise for the victim’s decision to invest, complimenting their foresight and financial acumen. Dopamine Effect: Receiving praise and recognition boosts the victim’s self-esteem and dopamine levels, making them more likely to continue investing.

Example: Highlighting Influencer Endorsements

Fake Endorsements by Influencers: The scammer falsely claims that well-known financial influencers or celebrities endorse the investment. Dopamine Effect: Believing that respected figures support the investment validates the victim’s choice, releasing dopamine and increasing their commitment.

Social Media Campaigns: The scammer runs social media campaigns featuring fake endorsements, high-quality graphics, and success stories. Dopamine Effect: The professional appearance and perceived social validation from influencers enhance the victim’s dopamine response, making the scam seem more credible.

Example: Exclusive Investment Opportunities

Offering VIP Status: The scammer offers the victim exclusive investment opportunities or VIP status within the investment scheme. Dopamine Effect: Feeling privileged and part of an exclusive group releases dopamine, making the victim feel special and more invested in the scam.

Limited-Time Offers: The scammer creates a sense of urgency with limited-time offers, making the victim feel they are getting a unique opportunity. Dopamine Effect: The anticipation of securing a rare deal boosts dopamine levels, driving the victim to act quickly and invest more money.

Crypto investment scammers skillfully leverage social validation and approval to manipulate their victims, exploiting dopamine-driven responses to build trust and excitement. By sharing success stories, engaging in online communities, providing personalized feedback, highlighting influencer endorsements, and offering exclusive opportunities, scammers create a powerful psychological bond with their victims. Understanding these tactics can help individuals recognize the signs of manipulation and protect themselves from falling victim to such scams.

Examples of How Sextortion Scammers Use Social Validation and Approval

Example: Flattering Messages and Attention

Compliments and Flattery: The scammer showers the victim with compliments and flattery, praising their appearance and personality. Dopamine Effect: Receiving compliments triggers dopamine release, making the victim feel valued and appreciated, which strengthens their emotional attachment to the scammer.

Consistent Attention: The scammer provides consistent and focused attention, making the victim feel special and important. Dopamine Effect: The steady flow of attention and approval increases dopamine levels, fostering a sense of connection and trust with the scammer.

Example: Creation of a Romantic or Intimate Relationship

Building a Romantic Narrative: The scammer constructs a romantic narrative, expressing deep feelings and intentions towards the victim. Dopamine Effect: The development of an intimate relationship releases dopamine, as the victim feels emotionally connected and anticipates a future together.

Sharing Personal Stories: The scammer shares personal stories and experiences, creating a sense of intimacy and trust. Dopamine Effect: The reciprocal sharing of personal information enhances dopamine release, as the victim feels they are forming a genuine bond with the scammer.

Example: Engaging in Mutual Interests and Activities

Discussing Common Interests: The scammer engages in conversations about shared interests and hobbies, making the victim feel understood and aligned. Dopamine Effect: Discovering common interests triggers dopamine release, reinforcing the victim’s sense of connection and validation from the scammer.

Participating in Online Activities Together: The scammer participates in online activities or games that the victim enjoys, creating a sense of companionship. Dopamine Effect: Engaging in enjoyable activities together increases dopamine levels, strengthening the emotional bond with the scammer.

Example: Providing Emotional Support and Understanding

Offering Emotional Support: The scammer offers emotional support, especially to teens or even adults, showing empathy and understanding. Dopamine Effect: Receiving support and empathy releases dopamine, making the victim feel valued and comforted, deepening their trust in the scammer.

Validating Feelings and Experiences: The scammer validates the victim’s feelings and experiences, reinforcing their emotions and perspectives. Dopamine Effect: Feeling understood and validated boosts dopamine levels, enhancing the victim’s emotional reliance on the scammer.

Sextortion scammers skillfully leverage social validation and approval to manipulate their victims, exploiting dopamine-driven responses to build trust and emotional attachment. By using flattering messages, creating romantic or intimate relationships, engaging in mutual interests, providing emotional support, and fostering a sense of community, scammers create a powerful psychological bond with their victims. Understanding these tactics can help individuals recognize the signs of manipulation and protect themselves from falling victim to such scams.

5. Dopamine Signaling – Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Technique:

Manipulators use the fear of missing out on rewards or social connections to drive behavior.

How it works:

FOMO leverages the brain’s reward system by creating a sense of urgency and potential loss. The possibility of missing out on a rewarding experience increases dopamine-driven anxiety, compelling individuals to take action.

A Generalized Example:

Limited-time offers and exclusive events create a sense of urgency, pushing individuals to make quick decisions to avoid missing out on potential rewards.

Examples of How Relationship Scammers Use the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Dopamine signaling plays a crucial role in various aspects of human behavior, including motivation, reward, and reinforcement learning.

Here are a few examples of dopamine signaling related to Fear of Missing Out (FOMO):

Reward anticipation: Dopamine neurons become activated when an individual anticipates a reward. For instance, when someone is about to receive a delicious meal or a monetary reward, dopamine levels rise in anticipation.

Pleasure response: Dopamine is often associated with the feeling of pleasure. Activities such as eating, listening to music, or engaging in enjoyable social interactions can trigger dopamine release, contributing to feelings of happiness and satisfaction.

Motivation and goal-directed behavior: Dopamine plays a key role in motivating individuals to pursue goals and rewards. When people set and achieve goals, dopamine levels increase, reinforcing the behavior and encouraging them to continue striving for success.

Addiction: Many addictive substances and behaviors, such as drugs, gambling, and certain types of compulsive behaviors, directly or indirectly affect the brain’s dopamine system. These substances and activities can hijack the brain’s reward circuitry, leading to compulsive use despite negative consequences.

Examples used in Relationship Scams:

Example: Creating a sense of urgency: Scammers may use tactics that trigger dopamine release by creating a sense of urgency or scarcity. For example, they might claim that an opportunity for love or financial gain is only available for a limited time, exploiting the fear of missing out on something valuable.

Example: Offering rewards and validation: Scammers often use flattery, compliments, and promises of love or affection to manipulate their victims. By appealing to the victim’s desire for social validation and positive reinforcement (which are associated with dopamine release), they can establish an emotional connection and build trust.

Example: Providing intermittent rewards: Similar to the principles of intermittent reinforcement in addiction, scammers may intermittently provide rewards or positive feedback to keep the victim engaged. This can create a pattern of anticipation and reward that reinforces the victim’s continued involvement in the scam.

Exploiting vulnerability: Scammers may target individuals who are experiencing loneliness, low self-esteem, or other emotional vulnerabilities. By offering companionship, support, and validation, they can exploit the victim’s desire for connection and belonging, triggering dopamine release associated with social interactions.

Examples of How Crypto Investment Scammers use the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Dopamine signaling is closely linked to motivation, reward, and reinforcement learning in the brain. Here are some examples of dopamine signaling:

Reward anticipation: Dopamine neurons become activated when individuals anticipate a reward. For example, when someone expects to earn money or experience a pleasurable outcome, dopamine levels rise in anticipation.

Pleasure response: Dopamine is associated with the feeling of pleasure. Engaging in enjoyable activities, such as eating tasty food or participating in social interactions, can trigger dopamine release, contributing to feelings of happiness and satisfaction.

Motivation and goal-directed behavior: Dopamine plays a crucial role in motivating individuals to pursue goals and rewards. When people set objectives and achieve them, dopamine levels increase, reinforcing the behavior and encouraging further goal-directed actions.

Addiction: Many addictive substances and behaviors, including drugs, gambling, and certain compulsive behaviors, impact the brain’s dopamine system. These substances and activities can hijack the brain’s reward circuitry, leading to compulsive use despite adverse consequences.

Examples used in Crypto Investment Scams:

Example: Creating a sense of urgency: Scammers often create a sense of urgency by claiming that a particular cryptocurrency investment opportunity is time-limited or that prices are about to skyrocket. They leverage FOMO by suggesting that if the victim doesn’t act quickly, they’ll miss out on significant financial gains, triggering dopamine release associated with anticipation of rewards.

Example: Promising high returns: Scammers entice victims by promising unrealistically high returns on investment in cryptocurrencies. These promises activate dopamine signaling related to the anticipation of financial rewards, leading individuals to overlook potential risks in pursuit of perceived gains.

Example: Social validation: Crypto investment scammers may use social proof tactics to validate their schemes. They might claim that many others have already invested and profited from the opportunity, appealing to the victim’s desire for social validation and triggering dopamine release associated with positive social interactions.

Example: Exploiting uncertainty: Cryptocurrency markets are often characterized by volatility and uncertainty, factors that can amplify FOMO. Scammers capitalize on this by spreading misinformation or exaggerated claims about the potential for massive profits, creating a sense of urgency and excitement that triggers dopamine release.

Examples of How Sextortion Scammers use the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Dopamine signaling in the brain is intricately linked to motivation, reward processing, and reinforcement learning. Here are some examples of dopamine signaling:

Reward anticipation: Dopamine neurons become active when individuals anticipate a reward. For instance, when someone expects to experience pleasure or gain a positive outcome, dopamine levels increase in anticipation of that reward.

Pleasure response: Dopamine is often associated with the feeling of pleasure. Engaging in enjoyable activities, such as eating delicious food, engaging in sexual activity, or receiving positive social interactions, can trigger dopamine release, contributing to feelings of happiness and satisfaction.

Motivation and goal-directed behavior: Dopamine plays a crucial role in motivating individuals to pursue goals and rewards. When people set objectives and work towards achieving them, dopamine levels increase, reinforcing the behavior and encouraging continued effort towards those goals.

Addiction: Many addictive substances and behaviors, including drugs, gambling, and certain compulsive behaviors, directly impact the brain’s dopamine system. These substances and activities can hijack the brain’s reward circuitry, leading to compulsive use despite negative consequences.

Examples used in Sextortion Scams:

Example: Creating a sense of urgency: Sextortion scammers often create a sense of urgency by claiming to have compromising or explicit images or videos of the victim. They may threaten to release this material to the victim’s friends, family, or colleagues unless a ransom is paid promptly. This threat triggers FOMO, as victims fear the potential social consequences of the material being released, leading to increased dopamine release associated with the anticipation of avoiding those consequences.

Example: Promising resolution and relief: Scammers offer victims a resolution to the threat of embarrassment or harm by complying with their demands. Victims may experience relief and a sense of reward when they believe that paying the ransom will resolve the situation, leading to dopamine release associated with the anticipation of relief from stress or anxiety.

Example: Exploiting emotional vulnerability: Sextortion scammers often target individuals who are emotionally vulnerable or susceptible to manipulation. They may use tactics such as flattery, manipulation, or emotional blackmail to elicit compliance from their victims. Victims may experience a sense of validation or relief from the attention or validation provided by the scammer, triggering dopamine release associated with positive social interactions.

Example: Leveraging social pressure: Scammers may claim that many others have already complied with their demands or that they have evidence of widespread dissemination of the compromising material. This tactic exploits social pressure and the fear of being singled out or ostracized, triggering dopamine release associated with the desire to avoid social rejection or embarrassment.

6. Dopamine Signaling – Emotional Manipulation

Technique:

Manipulators exploit emotional highs and lows to control behavior and maintain influence.

How it works:

Emotional experiences, both positive and negative, can trigger dopamine release. Manipulators may create cycles of emotional highs (through praise, and gifts) followed by lows (criticism, withdrawal) to keep the target off-balance and dependent on their approval.

A Generalized Example:

In an abusive relationship, the abuser might alternate between affectionate behavior and emotional abuse, keeping the victim emotionally dependent and striving for the return of positive interactions.

Examples of How Relationship Scammers Use Emotional Manipulation

Dopamine signaling in emotional manipulation, often employed by relationship scammers, can exploit the dopamine system in several ways. Here are some examples:

Example: Love bombing: Love bombing involves overwhelming someone with affection, attention, and declarations of love in the initial stages of a relationship. This flood of positive emotions can hyperactivity the Amygdala in the victim’s brain triggering dopamine release leading to feelings of happiness and attachment. Relationship scammers rely on the use of love bombing to quickly establish a deep emotional connection with their victims, making it harder for them to see through deceptive intentions.

Example: Intermittent reinforcement: Intermittent reinforcement is a psychological principle where rewards or punishments are given inconsistently in response to specific behaviors. In the context of relationship scams, scammers may intermittently provide affection, validation, or promises of a future together, interspersed with periods of withdrawal or manipulation. This pattern keeps the victim emotionally invested and seeking validation, leading to a cycle of dopamine release in response to the intermittent rewards.

Example: Isolation and dependency: Relationship scammers often isolate their victims from friends, family, and other sources of support, creating a sense of dependency on the scammer for emotional fulfillment and validation. This isolation can trigger stress and anxiety in the victim, leading to heightened dopamine release when the scammer provides reassurance or affection, reinforcing the dependency on the scammer for emotional well-being.

Example: Gaslighting and manipulation: Gaslighting involves manipulating someone into doubting their own perceptions, memories, and sanity. Relationship scammers may gaslight their victims by denying or minimizing abusive behavior, blaming the victim for problems in the relationship, or undermining their self-confidence. This manipulation can lead to feelings of confusion, self-doubt, and emotional distress in the victim, which may be accompanied by dopamine release as the victim seeks validation and reassurance from the scammer.

Example: Promises of a better future: Relationship scammers often maintain control of their victims with promises of a better future together, such as marriage, financial stability, or emotional fulfillment. These promises tap into the victim’s desires for security, happiness, and fulfillment, triggering dopamine release as they envision a positive outcome. However, the scammer’s intentions may be deceptive, leading the victim to experience disappointment and emotional distress when the promises are not fulfilled.

Examples of How Crypto Investment Scammers Use Emotional Manipulation

Crypto investment scammers may employ emotional manipulation techniques to exploit the dopamine system in several ways. Here are some examples:

Example: Promising high returns: Crypto investment scammers often make unrealistic promises of high returns on investment to lure victims into their schemes. These promises tap into the victim’s desire for financial gain and security, triggering dopamine release as they anticipate the potential rewards. The anticipation of significant profits can override rational decision-making and lead individuals to invest without fully considering the risks involved.

Example: Fear of Missing Out (FOMO): Scammers leverage the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) by creating a sense of urgency and scarcity around their investment opportunities. They may claim that prices are about to skyrocket or that the opportunity is only available for a limited time, triggering dopamine release as individuals fear missing out on potential gains. This emotional manipulation tactic encourages impulsive decision-making and prompts individuals to invest hastily without conducting proper due diligence.

Example: Social validation: Crypto investment scammers may use social proof tactics to validate their schemes and create a sense of legitimacy. They may showcase fake testimonials or boast about the success stories of purported investors, triggering dopamine release as individuals seek social validation and reassurance. The perceived endorsement from others can influence individuals to invest based on emotions rather than rational analysis.

Example: Exploiting emotions during market fluctuations: Scammers may exploit emotions during periods of market volatility to manipulate investors. For example, they may spread misinformation or sensationalize news to induce panic selling or buying, triggering dopamine release as individuals react emotionally to market movements. By exacerbating fear or greed, scammers can manipulate investor behavior and capitalize on their emotional vulnerability for personal gain.

Example: Creating a sense of belonging: Crypto investment scammers may foster a sense of belonging and community among their victims to increase loyalty and engagement. They may create online forums or social media groups where investors can interact and share experiences, triggering dopamine release as individuals feel a sense of camaraderie and belonging. This emotional connection can make it more difficult for victims to question the legitimacy of the investment scheme and may lead them to ignore warning signs of potential fraud.

Examples of How Sextortion Scammers Use Emotional Manipulation

Sextortion scammers may employ emotional manipulation tactics to exploit the dopamine system in several ways. Here are some examples:

Example: Creating fear and anxiety: Sextortion scammers often initiate contact with their victims by sending threatening messages claiming to have compromising or explicit material, such as intimate photos or videos. These threats induce fear and anxiety in the victim, triggering stress responses and leading to increased dopamine release as the victim seeks relief from the perceived threat.

Example: Offering a solution: Scammers typically offer a solution to the victim’s distress in exchange for compliance with their demands. For example, they may promise to delete the compromising material or refrain from sharing it if the victim pays a ransom or provides additional explicit content. This promise of resolution induces relief in the victim and triggers dopamine release associated with the anticipation of escaping the threat.

Example: Exploiting shame and embarrassment: Sextortion scammers leverage the fear of public humiliation and social stigma associated with the release of intimate material to manipulate their victims. They may threaten to share the material with the victim’s friends, family, or colleagues, inducing feelings of shame, embarrassment, and social isolation. These negative emotions trigger dopamine release as the victim seeks to avoid the potential consequences of exposure.

Example: Manipulating empathy and guilt: Scammers may employ emotional manipulation tactics to evoke empathy and guilt in their victims. For example, they may claim to be in dire financial circumstances or facing personal hardships, appealing to the victim’s sense of compassion. By eliciting feelings of guilt and responsibility, scammers can increase the likelihood of compliance with their demands, triggering dopamine release as the victim seeks to alleviate their emotional distress.

Example: Creating a sense of urgency: Sextortion scammers often impose deadlines or time limits for compliance with their demands, creating a sense of urgency and pressure on the victim. This urgency induces stress and anxiety, triggering dopamine release as the victim seeks to resolve the situation quickly and avoid potential negative consequences.

7. Dopamine Signaling – Anchoring and Association

Technique:

Manipulators link specific stimuli or contexts with positive outcomes to anchor behaviors and responses.

How it works:

By repeatedly pairing certain actions, objects, or environments with rewarding experiences, manipulators can create strong associative memories that trigger dopamine release when the target encounters these stimuli.

A Generalized Example:

A salesperson might create a luxurious, pleasurable shopping experience that customers associate with the positive emotions of the environment, encouraging them to make purchases to relieve those feelings.

Examples of How Relationship Scammers Use Anchoring and Association

Relationship scammers exploit dopamine signaling through anchoring and association techniques to manipulate their victims. Here are some examples:

Example: Anchoring: Anchoring is a cognitive bias where individuals rely heavily on the first piece of information they receive when making decisions. Relationship scammers may use anchoring by presenting themselves in an initial interaction as charming, charismatic, and trustworthy. This positive first impression can anchor the victim’s perception of the scammer, leading them to overlook warning signs or red flags later on. Dopamine release occurs as the victim forms a positive association with the scammer based on the initial interaction, reinforcing trust and attachment.

Example: Association: Association involves linking two unrelated concepts or stimuli in the mind. Relationship scammers may associate themselves with desirable traits or experiences to manipulate their victims. For example, they may claim to share similar interests, values, or life goals with the victim, creating a sense of connection and compatibility. By associating themselves with positive attributes or experiences, scammers trigger dopamine release in the victim’s brain, reinforcing the perception of the scammer as an ideal partner or confidant.

Example: Creating emotional anchors: Relationship scammers may create emotional anchors by manipulating significant events or milestones in the victim’s life. For example, they may exploit birthdays, anniversaries, or other special occasions to strengthen their emotional connection with the victim. By associating themselves with positive emotions or memorable experiences, scammers trigger dopamine release in the victim’s brain, reinforcing the bond between them and the scammer.

Example: Using shared experiences: Relationship scammers may exploit shared experiences or intimate conversations to deepen their emotional connection with the victim. They may use tactics such as mirroring the victim’s language, emotions, or gestures to create a sense of rapport and understanding. By associating themselves with positive interactions and shared experiences, scammers trigger dopamine release in the victim’s brain, reinforcing the perception of a deep and meaningful connection.

Examples of How Crypto Investment Scammers Use Anchoring and Association

Crypto investment scammers may leverage anchoring and association techniques to exploit dopamine signaling and manipulate their victims. Here are some examples:

Example: Anchoring with Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs): Crypto investment scammers often use anchoring by presenting their investment opportunity during Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) as groundbreaking, revolutionary, or exclusive. By anchoring the victim’s perception of the investment at an early stage when excitement and hype are high, scammers can create a positive first impression that influences subsequent decision-making. This anchoring effect triggers dopamine release as the victim associates the investment with the initial excitement and potential for significant returns.

Example: Association with Success Stories: Scammers may associate their investment scheme with success stories or testimonials from purported investors who claim to have achieved extraordinary returns. By showcasing these testimonials on their websites or social media platforms, scammers create an association between their investment opportunity and financial success. This association triggers dopamine release in potential investors as they envision themselves achieving similar levels of success, reinforcing the appeal of the investment.

Example: Anchoring with Price Predictions: Crypto investment scammers often anchor their victims’ expectations by making bold price predictions or projections for the cryptocurrency they are promoting. These predictions may be exaggerated or based on misleading information but serve to anchor the victim’s perception of the investment’s potential value. As a result, the victim may become emotionally attached to the idea of achieving the predicted returns, leading to dopamine release associated with anticipation of future rewards.

Example: Association with Trustworthy Sources: Scammers may associate their investment scheme with seemingly trustworthy sources, such as reputable financial institutions, industry experts, or well-known personalities. By leveraging these associations, scammers enhance the perceived legitimacy of their investment opportunity and instill confidence in potential investors. This association triggers dopamine release as investors perceive the investment as credible and trustworthy, reinforcing their willingness to participate.

Example: Anchoring with Limited-Time Offers: Crypto investment scammers often use anchoring by presenting their investment opportunity as time-limited or exclusive. They may claim that the opportunity is only available to a select group of investors or for a limited time, creating a sense of urgency and scarcity. This anchoring effect triggers dopamine release as investors fear missing out on the opportunity, reinforcing their motivation to invest before the deadline expires.

Examples of How Sextortion Scammers Use Anchoring and Association

Sextortion scammers may utilize anchoring and association techniques to exploit dopamine signaling and manipulate their victims. Here are some examples:

Example: Anchoring with Initial Contact: Sextortion scammers often initiate contact with their victims through unsolicited messages or emails claiming to have compromising or explicit material, such as intimate photos or videos. This initial contact serves as an anchor, setting the tone for the subsequent interaction and framing the victim’s perception of the scammer’s power and control. Dopamine release occurs as the victim’s brain processes the initial shock and fear associated with the threat, reinforcing the scammer’s influence over the victim.

Example: Association with Fear and Anxiety: Scammers associate their threats of exposing sensitive material with fear and anxiety-inducing scenarios, such as damaging the victim’s reputation, ruining relationships, or causing financial harm. By linking their demands with these negative consequences, scammers trigger stress responses in the victim’s brain, leading to increased dopamine release as the victim seeks relief from the perceived threat.

Example: Anchoring with False Evidence: Sextortion scammers may provide false evidence or fabricated proof of the compromising material they claim to possess, such as edited photos or misleading screenshots. This false evidence serves as an anchor, shaping the victim’s perception of the threat and reinforcing the credibility of the scammer’s claims. Dopamine release occurs as the victim’s brain processes the perceived threat and evaluates potential strategies for mitigating the risk.

Example: Association with Compliance and Relief: Scammers associate compliance with their demands, such as paying a ransom or providing additional explicit material, with relief from the perceived threat and anxiety. By offering a solution to the victim’s distress, scammers trigger dopamine release as the victim anticipates the potential for escaping the threat and returning to a state of emotional equilibrium.

Example: Anchoring with Deadline Pressure: Sextortion scammers often impose deadlines or time limits for compliance with their demands, creating a sense of urgency and pressure on the victim. This anchoring effect triggers dopamine release as the victim’s brain processes the perceived threat of impending consequences and evaluates the potential risks and rewards of complying with the scammer’s demands.

Recognizing and Resisting Dopamine-Based Manipulation

Awareness: Understanding how dopamine influences your behavior can help you recognize when it’s being exploited. Pay attention to your emotional responses and the triggers that lead to heightened states of excitement, anticipation, or craving.

Mindfulness: Practice mindfulness to stay grounded and make conscious decisions. Being aware of your internal states can reduce the automaticity of dopamine-driven behaviors.

Critical Thinking: Question the motives behind rewards and praise. Consider whether the positive reinforcement you receive is being used to manipulate your behavior for someone else’s gain.

Setting Boundaries: Establish clear boundaries and stick to them. Avoid situations where you feel pressured to act against your better judgment due to the promise of rewards or fear of missing out.

Seek Support: If you feel manipulated, seek advice from trusted friends, family, or professionals who can provide an outside perspective and support your autonomy.

By understanding these techniques and their impact on dopamine signaling, you can better recognize and resist manipulation, maintaining greater control over your decisions and actions.

Summary

Dopamine signaling plays a crucial role in how we experience rewards and make decisions. Scammers exploit this system by creating scenarios that trigger dopamine release, manipulating victims’ emotions and behaviors. Understanding this mechanism highlights the importance of awareness and education in preventing scams, as well as the need for strategies to protect and support victims who may be biologically predisposed to fall for manipulative tactics.

Related Information

The manipulation tactics used by relationship scammers, crypto investment scammers, and sextortion scammers often leverage dopamine signaling in the brain to control their victims. Here’s a breakdown of how these tactics work, supported by recent studies:

Dopamine and Reward Mechanisms:

Scammers exploit the brain’s reward system by creating situations that trigger dopamine release, which reinforces certain behaviors. For example, in relationship scams, victims receive affectionate messages and attention, which activate dopamine pathways similar to those triggered by genuine romantic interactions. This reinforcement makes victims more susceptible to manipulation and less likely to notice red flags​ (JNeurosci)​​ (ScienceDaily)​.

Transition from Goal-Directed to Habitual Behavior:

The manipulation tactics used by scammers can shift victims’ behavior from goal-directed actions to habitual responses. This is particularly evident in investment scams, where initial small rewards (returns on investment) lead to a habit of trust and further investment. Dopamine plays a crucial role in this shift by reinforcing repeated behaviors, eventually making them less sensitive to negative outcomes or risk evaluations​ (JNeurosci)​.

Emotional Manipulation and Cognitive Biases:

Sextortion scammers often use fear and urgency to manipulate victims. This type of emotional manipulation can significantly affect dopamine signaling, creating a heightened state of arousal and stress. Studies have shown that high levels of dopamine during stressful situations can impair decision-making and increase susceptibility to cognitive biases, making victims more likely to comply with demands to avoid perceived threats​ (ScienceDaily)​.

Habit Formation and Long-Term Behavioral Changes:

Chronic manipulation and repeated engagement with scammers can lead to long-term changes in brain structure and function. Research indicates that sustained exposure to manipulative tactics can enhance the formation of habits, driven by dopamine signaling pathways. This can lead to persistent behaviors even in the face of negative consequences, as seen in victims who continue to send money or personal information despite evidence of the scam​ (JNeurosci)​.

These studies highlight the significant role of dopamine in the manipulation strategies employed by various types of scammers. Understanding these mechanisms can help in developing better preventive measures and support systems for victims of such scams.

SCARS Resources:

• For New Victims of Relationship Scams www.ScamVictimsSupport.org
• Subscribe to SCARS Newsletter newsletter.againstscams.org
• Sign up for SCARS professional Support & Recovery Groups, visit support.AgainstScams.org
• Find competent Trauma Counselors or Therapists, visit counseling.AgainstScams.org
• Become a SCARS Member and get free counseling benefits, visit membership.AgainstScams.org
• Report each and every crime, learn how to at reporting.AgainstScams.org
• Learn More about Scams & Scammers at RomanceScamsNOW.com and ScamsNOW.com
• Scammer Photos on ScammerPhotos.com
• SCARS Videos youtube.AgainstScams.org
• Self-Help Books for Scam Victims are at shop.AgainstScams.org
• Donate to SCARS and help us help others at donate.AgainstScams.org

-/ 30 /-

What do you think about this?

Please share your thoughts in a comment below!